How we check a gluten verdict

Every verdict on Gluten Verdict starts from what the maker publishes about one US product: its own words, its ingredient list and any certifier listing, each read and dated by us. Where a row rests on our reading rather than the maker’s words, it says so. We never test food in a lab.

The verdicts for packaged products and menu items

Labeled gluten-free
The maker uses the “gluten-free” claim. Under the US rule, that claim means, among other things, that “any unavoidable presence of gluten in the food must be less than 20 ppm” (FDA).
Certified gluten-free
A third-party certifier lists the product in its public directory, and we link the listing.
Not labeled gluten-free
The ingredient list names no wheat, barley, rye, malt or oats, but the maker makes no gluten-free claim, so it promises nothing about shared equipment. When the maker adds a “may contain wheat” line, we show it beside the verdict.
Contains gluten
A gluten ingredient is listed, such as wheat flour or barley malt, or the maker says the product contains gluten.
Unknown
The sources don’t settle it. An unknown is never shown as a yes.

Two more for foods and ingredients

A food like rice or an ingredient like maltodextrin has no single maker, so its verdict says what the food is and the products table says what each brand does with it.

Naturally gluten-free
Its plain, usual US form has no wheat, barley, rye or oats in it, and at least two US authorities or celiac charities say so. Packaged versions can still differ, which the page’s conditions spell out. Grains, flours and starches can pick up gluten in harvesting and processing, so the Celiac Disease Foundation advises buying versions tested under 20 parts per million, the level a US gluten-free label requires; those pages say “Buy it labeled gluten-free” beside the verdict.
Depends on the product
Common US versions differ: some contain gluten and some don’t. The products table settles each one.

A food made from a gluten grain, such as couscous from wheat, gets Contains gluten “Contains gluten”. A chain’s menu gets one verdict per item, read from the chain’s own allergen guide, in the chain’s terms: “Chain says gluten-free” when the chain calls an item gluten-free, “Not called gluten-free” when its guide marks no gluten but makes no such claim, and “Depends on the order” for the menu as a whole.

Where each fact comes from

  1. The maker’s own product page, FAQ or allergen statement, quoted exactly.
  2. The current US ingredient list, from the maker’s product page or its SmartLabel page.
  3. A certifier’s public directory, searched by product and brand.
  4. For foods and ingredients, the US rules (FDA, USDA) and the celiac charities, quoted.
  5. For restaurant chains, the chain’s own current allergen guide.

Every source a verdict relies on is listed on it with the date we read it. Other “is it gluten-free” websites are never a source.

The shop and the gluten scanner

The shop lists a product only when its maker or a certifier says “gluten-free” for it; each card quotes the claim and its date. How shop links work says whether we are paid for them.

The gluten scanner reads the words of an ingredient list you scan, upload or paste and flags the names that mean gluten. It cannot see cross-contact or how a factory runs, and a photo can be misread.

What we don’t do

Who checks

Haider Shah runs Gluten Verdict. Each verdict lists the evidence and date for its US product or variant. A completed individual review names the reviewer and date. A verdict awaiting that check is marked pending.

Found something out of date? See the corrections log and tell us.